#Science explained

Pamela Richards on the architecture of intelligent teams

Dr Pamela RIchards, 19 Nov 2026

FIFA
left
right

Arrigo Sacchi, coach of the legendary AC Milan side of the late 1980s and early 1990s, used to say there were two keys to success: hard work, and ideas.

However, even the cleverest tacticians will struggle to make an impact unless their team can understand and implement those ideas. In short, before they can work as a unit, they need to think like one. In this presentation, Dr Pam Richards explores how building a shared mental framework within your team can help players understand exactly how you want them to play and, eventually, to implement that vision instinctively. The session is followed by an in-depth Q&A, hosted by FIFA’s Professor Paul Bradley.

Aims
  • Explain the theory of shared mental models and their potential to improve performance, especially in decision-making.

  • Set out the continuum of decision-making, from classical, rational approaches to instinctive “naturalistic” thinking.

  • Introduce a decision-making framework that can be applied to a range of team sports, including football, and explain how it can be built in the real world.

Conclusions
  • A well refined shared mental model within a team has the potential to put them one step ahead of their opposition by bridging the gap between theory and execution.

  • The alpha vision (the overall performance concept underlying your approach to coaching) is evidence-based. The beta vision is all about how to implement that concept by empowering support staff and players to contribute to it.

  • Space for reflection is key to establishing and refining your vision within a team, linking off-field training settings with dynamic, on-field competition.

Recommendations
  • Coaches can establish the alpha vision, but the players need to be instrumental in shaping the beta vision, because they will be responsible for implementing it on the pitch.

  • The approach outlined in this presentation is complex. It is important to build it up gradually, working within any constraints your team might be facing.

  • Prioritise creating an off-field environment that promotes reflection to enhance learning. This will help players consolidate what they learn, which will make it easier for them to apply their new skills when it counts.

Watch presentation

Welcome by Professor Paul Bradley
Part 1: The theory of mental models
Part 2: The continuum of theories
Part 3: Using theory to inform practice
Part 4: Case studies
Part 5: Q&A

Read summary

Part 1: The theory of mental models
Shared “mental models” provide the collective framework teams use to process and react to information. These mental models have two distinct parts: a technical component and a non-technical one. In a football context, the former influences how players control the ball and think in specific situations. By contrast, the non-technical component is about social cognition (including communication) and the social aspects of the game, such as attitude and teamwork. Establishing a shared mental model within a team can give players a common understanding of their roles, and help them to operate as a cohesive unit.

Part 2: The continuum of theories
Approaches to decision-making can be placed on a spectrum, with rational, “classical” decision-making at one end, and intuitive, “naturalistic” decision-making (NDM) on the other. Making decisions during a game requires a naturalistic approach, because players rarely get more than a few seconds to weigh their options. Reading the game rapidly in real matches requires a combination of off-field learning, reflection on performances, an understanding of what your team-mates are doing, and situational awareness. Taken together, these elements create a cyclic link and an environment that can simulate match-play.

Part 3: Using theory to inform practice
In this part of the presentation, Dr Richards considers how to apply this theory to real teams by using the STRIDE-MIND™ framework to build a shared mental model. Here, it is crucial to distinguish the “alpha vision” – a top-down concept outlining what the team should do – from the “beta vision”, which sets out how the vision will be operationalised and implemented in terms of skills, tactical thinking and behaviours, both on and off the pitch. Players need to be heavily involved in co-creating the beta vision, because they are responsible for delivering it.

Part 4: Case studies
To finish the session, Dr Richards shows the impact building shared mental models can have in a variety of team sports, including junior and senior football. The data highlights the potential benefits of shared mental models for performance, as well as underlining the importance of individual parts of the framework. For instance, asking players to reflect on short video clips after matches and write down a structured analysis can help shape tactical thinking, reinforce learning. and align them with how the coach wants the team to react in specific scenarios during games.

Q&A

00:25
You talked a lot about shared mental models. Could you explain a bit more about what they are, where they have been used, and how they can help coaches? 

02:32
Can you give us some more detail about alpha and beta vision, the differences between them, and how they tie into team performance?

06:45
How should practitioners prepare to apply the frameworks you set out in your presentation?

08:54
In these Science Explained sessions, we have had a number of debates about the role of instruction v. autonomy. From a decision-making perspective, how do you balance instruction with allowing players to find solutions for themselves?

11:59
Adaptability is so important in elite sport. How do you adapt a team’s shared understanding in the face o opponents who are constantly trying to disrupt your game plan? 

15:41
In a sport like football, language is key. How do you create a common language within a team that enables rapid decision-making under pressure?

18:18
What does integrating on- and off-field work effectively look like in practice? 

22:32
What role do reflection and debriefing play in improving decision-making ability?

24:54
What role does video play in developing collective understanding of play and honing decision-making?

27:15
Scenario-based learning is a fascinating approach. Can you tell us a bit more about it?

29:40
What are your key take-home messages for coaches?

About the expert

Rate your experience

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

The site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.